serverRequestCall: block until request received (#30)

* fix error for client timeouts

* registered calls: block until call received, simplify cleanup

* unregistered calls: block until request received

* Fix up tests

examples/echo/echo-server/Main.hs

@@ -1,5 +1,6 @@
 {-# LANGUAGE OverloadedLists   #-}
 {-# LANGUAGE OverloadedStrings #-}
+{-# LANGUAGE RecordWildCards #-}
 {-# OPTIONS_GHC -fno-warn-missing-signatures #-}
 {-# OPTIONS_GHC -fno-warn-unused-binds       #-}
 
@@ -13,9 +14,10 @@ import qualified Network.GRPC.LowLevel.Call.Unregistered as U
 serverMeta :: MetadataMap
 serverMeta = [("test_meta", "test_meta_value")]
 
-handler :: U.ServerCall -> ByteString -> MetadataMap -> MethodName
+handler :: U.ServerCall
+           -> ByteString
            -> IO (ByteString, MetadataMap, StatusCode, StatusDetails)
-handler _call reqBody _reqMeta _method = do
+handler U.ServerCall{..} reqBody = do
   --putStrLn $ "Got request for method: " ++ show method
   --putStrLn $ "Got metadata: " ++ show reqMeta
   return (reqBody, serverMeta, StatusOk, StatusDetails "")
@@ -23,7 +25,7 @@ handler _call reqBody _reqMeta _method = do
 unregMain :: IO ()
 unregMain = withGRPC $ \grpc -> do
   withServer grpc (ServerConfig "localhost" 50051 []) $ \server -> forever $ do
-    result <- U.serverHandleNormalCall server 15 serverMeta handler
+    result <- U.serverHandleNormalCall server serverMeta handler
     case result of
       Left x -> putStrLn $ "handle call result error: " ++ show x
       Right _ -> return ()
@@ -34,7 +36,7 @@ regMain = withGRPC $ \grpc -> do
   withServer grpc (ServerConfig "localhost" 50051 methods) $ \server ->
     forever $ do
       let method = head (registeredMethods server)
-      result <- serverHandleNormalCall server method 15 serverMeta $
+      result <- serverHandleNormalCall server method serverMeta $
         \_call reqBody _reqMeta -> return (reqBody, serverMeta, StatusOk,
                                            StatusDetails "")
       case result of
@@ -44,7 +46,7 @@ regMain = withGRPC $ \grpc -> do
 -- | loop to fork n times
 regLoop :: Server -> RegisteredMethod -> IO ()
 regLoop server method = forever $ do
-  result <- serverHandleNormalCall server method 15 serverMeta $
+  result <- serverHandleNormalCall server method serverMeta $
     \_call reqBody _reqMeta -> return (reqBody, serverMeta, StatusOk,
                                        StatusDetails "")
   case result of

src/Network/GRPC/LowLevel/Call.hs

@@ -65,10 +65,9 @@ clientCallCancel cc = C.grpcCallCancel (unClientCall cc) C.reserved
 -- the C state needed to respond to a registered call.
 data ServerCall = ServerCall
   { unServerCall        :: C.Call,
-    requestMetadataRecv :: Ptr C.MetadataArray,
+    requestMetadataRecv :: MetadataMap,
-    optionalPayload     :: Ptr C.ByteBuffer,
+    optionalPayload     :: Maybe ByteString,
     parentPtr           :: Maybe (Ptr C.Call),
-    callDeadlinePtr     :: C.CTimeSpecPtr,
     callDeadline        :: TimeSpec
   }
 
@@ -76,24 +75,6 @@ serverCallCancel :: ServerCall -> C.StatusCode -> String -> IO ()
 serverCallCancel sc code reason =
   C.grpcCallCancelWithStatus (unServerCall sc) code reason C.reserved
 
-serverCallGetMetadata :: ServerCall -> IO MetadataMap
-serverCallGetMetadata ServerCall{..} = do
-  marray <- peek requestMetadataRecv
-  C.getAllMetadataArray marray
-
--- | Extract the client request body from the given call, if present.  TODO: the
--- reason this returns @Maybe ByteString@ is because the gRPC library calls the
--- underlying out parameter "optional_payload". I am not sure exactly in what
--- cases it won't be present. The C++ library checks a has_request_payload_ bool
--- and passes in nullptr to request_registered_call if the bool is false, so we
--- may be able to do the payload present/absent check earlier.
-serverCallGetPayload :: ServerCall -> IO (Maybe ByteString)
-serverCallGetPayload ServerCall{..} = do
-  bb@(C.ByteBuffer rawPtr) <- peek optionalPayload
-  if rawPtr == nullPtr
-     then return Nothing
-     else Just <$> C.copyByteBufferToByteString bb
-
 serverCallIsExpired :: ServerCall -> IO Bool
 serverCallIsExpired sc = do
   currTime <- getTime Monotonic
@@ -110,24 +91,16 @@ debugClientCall = const $ return ()
 
 debugServerCall :: ServerCall -> IO ()
 #ifdef DEBUG
-debugServerCall call@(ServerCall (C.Call ptr) _ _ _ _ _) = do
+debugServerCall call@(ServerCall (C.Call ptr) _ _ _ _) = do
   grpcDebug $ "debugServerCall(R): server call: " ++ (show ptr)
   grpcDebug $ "debugServerCall(R): metadata ptr: "
               ++ show (requestMetadataRecv call)
-  metadataArr <- peek (requestMetadataRecv call)
-  metadata <- C.getAllMetadataArray metadataArr
-  grpcDebug $ "debugServerCall(R): metadata received: " ++ (show metadata)
   grpcDebug $ "debugServerCall(R): payload ptr: " ++ show (optionalPayload call)
-  payload <- peek (optionalPayload call)
-  bs <- C.copyByteBufferToByteString payload
-  grpcDebug $ "debugServerCall(R): payload contents: " ++ show bs
   forM_ (parentPtr call) $ \parentPtr' -> do
     grpcDebug $ "debugServerCall(R): parent ptr: " ++ show parentPtr'
     (C.Call parent) <- peek parentPtr'
     grpcDebug $ "debugServerCall(R): parent: " ++ show parent
   grpcDebug $ "debugServerCall(R): deadline ptr: " ++ show (callDeadline call)
-  timespec <- peek (callDeadlinePtr call)
-  grpcDebug $ "debugServerCall(R): deadline: " ++ show (C.timeSpec timespec)
 #else
 {-# INLINE debugServerCall #-}
 debugServerCall = const $ return ()
@@ -144,11 +117,5 @@ destroyServerCall call@ServerCall{..} = do
   debugServerCall call
   grpcDebug $ "Destroying server-side call object: " ++ show unServerCall
   C.grpcCallDestroy unServerCall
-  grpcDebug $ "destroying metadata array: " ++ show requestMetadataRecv
-  C.metadataArrayDestroy requestMetadataRecv
-  grpcDebug $ "destroying optional payload" ++ show optionalPayload
-  C.destroyReceivingByteBuffer optionalPayload
   grpcDebug $ "freeing parentPtr: " ++ show parentPtr
   forM_ parentPtr free
-  grpcDebug $ "destroying deadline." ++ show callDeadline
-  C.timespecDestroy callDeadlinePtr

src/Network/GRPC/LowLevel/Call/Unregistered.hs

@@ -6,6 +6,8 @@ import           Control.Monad
 import           Foreign.Marshal.Alloc        (free)
 import           Foreign.Ptr                  (Ptr)
 import           Foreign.Storable             (peek)
+import           System.Clock                 (TimeSpec)
+
 import           Network.GRPC.LowLevel.Call   (Host (..), MethodName (..))
 import           Network.GRPC.LowLevel.GRPC   (MetadataMap, grpcDebug)
 import qualified Network.GRPC.Unsafe          as C
@@ -17,28 +19,17 @@ import qualified Network.GRPC.Unsafe.Op as C
 -- call.
 data ServerCall = ServerCall
   { unServerCall        :: C.Call
-  , requestMetadataRecv :: Ptr C.MetadataArray
+  , requestMetadataRecv :: MetadataMap
   , parentPtr           :: Maybe (Ptr C.Call)
-  , callDetails         :: C.CallDetails
+  , callDeadline        :: TimeSpec
+  , callMethod          :: MethodName
+  , callHost            :: Host
   }
 
 serverCallCancel :: ServerCall -> C.StatusCode -> String -> IO ()
 serverCallCancel sc code reason =
   C.grpcCallCancelWithStatus (unServerCall sc) code reason C.reserved
 
-serverCallGetMetadata :: ServerCall -> IO MetadataMap
-serverCallGetMetadata ServerCall{..} = do
-  marray <- peek requestMetadataRecv
-  C.getAllMetadataArray marray
-
-serverCallGetMethodName :: ServerCall -> IO MethodName
-serverCallGetMethodName ServerCall{..} =
-  MethodName <$> C.callDetailsGetMethod callDetails
-
-serverCallGetHost :: ServerCall -> IO Host
-serverCallGetHost ServerCall{..} =
-  Host <$> C.callDetailsGetHost callDetails
-
 debugServerCall :: ServerCall -> IO ()
 #ifdef DEBUG
 debugServerCall call@(ServerCall (C.Call ptr) _ _ _) = do
@@ -66,9 +57,5 @@ destroyServerCall call@ServerCall{..} = do
   debugServerCall call
   grpcDebug $ "Destroying server-side call object: " ++ show unServerCall
   C.grpcCallDestroy unServerCall
-  grpcDebug $ "destroying metadata array: " ++ show requestMetadataRecv
-  C.metadataArrayDestroy requestMetadataRecv
   grpcDebug $ "freeing parentPtr: " ++ show parentPtr
   forM_ parentPtr free
-  grpcDebug $ "destroying call details: " ++ show callDetails
-  C.destroyCallDetails callDetails

src/Network/GRPC/LowLevel/CompletionQueue.hs

@@ -34,6 +34,7 @@ import           Control.Concurrent.STM                  (atomically, check)
 import           Control.Concurrent.STM.TVar             (newTVarIO, readTVar,
                                                           writeTVar)
 import           Control.Exception                       (bracket)
+import           Control.Monad                           (liftM2)
 import           Data.IORef                              (newIORef)
 import           Data.List                               (intersperse)
 import           Foreign.Marshal.Alloc                   (free, malloc)
@@ -51,6 +52,8 @@ import           System.Timeout                          (timeout)
 import           Network.GRPC.LowLevel.Call
 import           Network.GRPC.LowLevel.GRPC
 import           Network.GRPC.LowLevel.CompletionQueue.Internal
+import qualified Network.GRPC.Unsafe.ByteBuffer as C
+import qualified Network.GRPC.Unsafe.Metadata   as C
 
 withCompletionQueue :: GRPC -> (CompletionQueue -> IO a) -> IO a
 withCompletionQueue grpc = bracket (createCompletionQueue grpc)
@@ -131,18 +134,17 @@ channelCreateCall
 -- | Create the call object to handle a registered call.
 serverRequestCall :: C.Server
                   -> CompletionQueue
-                  -> TimeoutSeconds
                   -> RegisteredMethod
                   -> IO (Either GRPCIOError ServerCall)
 serverRequestCall
-  server cq@CompletionQueue{..} timeLimit RegisteredMethod{..} =
+  server cq@CompletionQueue{..} RegisteredMethod{..} =
-    withPermission Push cq $ do
+    withPermission Push cq $
-      -- NOTE: the below stuff is freed when we free the call we return.
+      bracket (liftM2 (,) malloc malloc)
-      deadlinePtr <- malloc
+              (\(p1,p2) -> free p1 >> free p2)
-      callPtr <- malloc
+              $ \(deadlinePtr, callPtr) ->
-      metadataArrayPtr <- C.metadataArrayCreate
+        C.withByteBufferPtr $ \bbPtr ->
+          C.withMetadataArrayPtr $ \metadataArrayPtr -> do
             metadataArray <- peek metadataArrayPtr
-      bbPtr <- malloc
             tag <- newTag cq
             grpcDebug $ "serverRequestCall(R): tag is " ++ show tag
             callError <- C.grpcServerRequestRegisteredCall
@@ -152,40 +154,49 @@ serverRequestCall
                          ++ show callError
             if callError /= C.CallOk
                then do grpcDebug "serverRequestCall(R): callError. cleaning up"
-                 failureCleanup deadlinePtr callPtr metadataArrayPtr bbPtr
                        return $ Left $ GRPCIOCallError callError
-         else do pluckResult <- pluck cq tag (Just timeLimit)
+               else do pluckResult <- pluck cq tag Nothing
-                 grpcDebug "serverRequestCall(R): finished pluck."
+                       grpcDebug $ "serverRequestCall(R): finished pluck:"
+                                   ++ show pluckResult
                        case pluckResult of
                          Left x -> do
                            grpcDebug "serverRequestCall(R): cleanup pluck err"
-                     failureCleanup deadlinePtr callPtr metadataArrayPtr bbPtr
                            return $ Left x
                          Right () -> do
                            rawCall <- peek callPtr
                            deadline <- convertDeadline deadlinePtr
-                     let assembledCall = ServerCall rawCall metadataArrayPtr
+                           payload <- convertPayload bbPtr
-                                           bbPtr Nothing deadlinePtr deadline
+                           meta <- convertMeta metadataArrayPtr
+                           let assembledCall = ServerCall rawCall
+                                                          meta
+                                                          payload
+                                                          Nothing
+                                                          deadline
+                           grpcDebug "serverRequestCall(R): About to return"
                            return $ Right assembledCall
-      --TODO: the gRPC library appears to hold onto these pointers for a random
+      where convertDeadline deadline = do
-      -- amount of time, even after returning from the only call that uses them.
-      -- This results in malloc errors if
-      -- gRPC tries to modify them after we free them. To work around it,
-      -- we sleep for a while before freeing the objects. We should find a
-      -- permanent solution that's more robust.
-      where failureCleanup deadline callPtr metadataArrayPtr bbPtr = forkIO $ do
-              threadDelaySecs 30
-              grpcDebug "serverRequestCall(R): doing delayed cleanup."
-              C.timespecDestroy deadline
-              free callPtr
-              C.metadataArrayDestroy metadataArrayPtr
-              free bbPtr
-            convertDeadline deadline = do
               --gRPC gives us a deadline that is just a delta, so we convert it
               --to a proper deadline.
               deadline' <- C.timeSpec <$> peek deadline
               now <- getTime Monotonic
               return $ now + deadline'
+            convertPayload bbPtr = do
+              -- TODO: the reason this returns @Maybe ByteString@ is because the
+              -- gRPC library calls the  underlying out parameter
+              -- "optional_payload". I am not sure exactly in what cases it
+              -- won't be present. The C++ library checks a
+              -- has_request_payload_ bool and passes in nullptr to
+              -- request_registered_call if the bool is false, so we
+              -- may be able to do the payload present/absent check earlier.
+              bb@(C.ByteBuffer rawPtr) <- peek bbPtr
+              if rawPtr == nullPtr
+                 then return Nothing
+                 else do bs <- C.copyByteBufferToByteString bb
+                         return $ Just bs
+            convertMeta requestMetadataRecv = do
+              mArray <- peek requestMetadataRecv
+              metamap <- C.getAllMetadataArray mArray
+              return metamap
 
 -- | Register the server's completion queue. Must be done before the server is
 -- started.

src/Network/GRPC/LowLevel/CompletionQueue/Internal.hs

@@ -121,6 +121,7 @@ pluck cq@CompletionQueue{..} tag waitSeconds = do
 eventToError :: C.Event -> (Either GRPCIOError a)
 eventToError (C.Event C.QueueShutdown _ _) = Left GRPCIOShutdown
 eventToError (C.Event C.QueueTimeout _ _) = Left GRPCIOTimeout
+eventToError (C.Event C.OpComplete False _) = Left GRPCIOTimeout
 eventToError _ = Left GRPCIOUnknownError
 
 -- | Returns true iff the given grpc_event was a success.

src/Network/GRPC/LowLevel/CompletionQueue/Unregistered.hs

@@ -3,6 +3,7 @@
 module Network.GRPC.LowLevel.CompletionQueue.Unregistered where
 
 import           Control.Concurrent                             (forkIO)
+import           Control.Exception                              (bracket)
 import           Foreign.Marshal.Alloc                          (free, malloc)
 import           Foreign.Storable                               (peek)
 import           Network.GRPC.LowLevel.Call
@@ -31,14 +32,13 @@ channelCreateCall chan parent mask cq@CompletionQueue{..} meth endpt deadline =
 
 serverRequestCall :: C.Server
                   -> CompletionQueue
-                  -> TimeoutSeconds
                   -> IO (Either GRPCIOError U.ServerCall)
-serverRequestCall server cq@CompletionQueue{..} timeLimit =
+serverRequestCall server cq@CompletionQueue{..} =
-  withPermission Push cq $ do
+  withPermission Push cq $
-    callPtr <- malloc
+    bracket malloc free $ \callPtr ->
+      C.withMetadataArrayPtr $ \metadataArrayPtr ->
+        C.withCallDetails $ \callDetails -> do
           grpcDebug $ "serverRequestCall: callPtr is " ++ show callPtr
-    callDetails <- C.createCallDetails
-    metadataArrayPtr <- C.metadataArrayCreate
           metadataArray <- peek metadataArrayPtr
           tag <- newTag cq
           callError <- C.grpcServerRequestCall server callPtr callDetails
@@ -46,35 +46,31 @@ serverRequestCall server cq@CompletionQueue{..} timeLimit =
           grpcDebug $ "serverRequestCall: callError was " ++ show callError
           if callError /= C.CallOk
              then do grpcDebug "serverRequestCall: got call error; cleaning up."
-               failureCleanup callPtr callDetails metadataArrayPtr
                      return $ Left $ GRPCIOCallError callError
-       else do pluckResult <- pluck cq tag (Just timeLimit)
+             else do pluckResult <- pluck cq tag Nothing
                      grpcDebug $ "serverRequestCall: pluckResult was "
                                  ++ show pluckResult
                      case pluckResult of
                        Left x -> do
-                   grpcDebug "serverRequestCall: pluck error; cleaning up."
+                         grpcDebug "serverRequestCall: pluck error."
-                   failureCleanup callPtr callDetails
-                                  metadataArrayPtr
                          return $ Left x
                        Right () -> do
                          rawCall <- peek callPtr
+                         metadata <- C.getAllMetadataArray metadataArray
+                         deadline <- getDeadline callDetails
+                         method <- getMethod callDetails
+                         host <- getHost callDetails
                          let call = U.ServerCall rawCall
-                                           metadataArrayPtr
+                                                 metadata
                                                  Nothing
-                                           callDetails
+                                                 deadline
+                                                 method
+                                                 host
                          return $ Right call
 
-      --TODO: the gRPC library appears to hold onto these pointers for a random
+      where getDeadline callDetails = do
-      -- amount of time, even after returning from the only call that uses them.
+              C.timeSpec <$> C.callDetailsGetDeadline callDetails
-      -- This results in malloc errors if
+            getMethod callDetails =
-      -- gRPC tries to modify them after we free them. To work around it,
+              MethodName <$> C.callDetailsGetMethod callDetails
-      -- we sleep for a while before freeing the objects. We should find a
+            getHost callDetails =
-      -- permanent solution that's more robust.
+              Host <$> C.callDetailsGetHost callDetails
-      where failureCleanup callPtr callDetails metadataArrayPtr = forkIO $ do
-              threadDelaySecs 30
-              grpcDebug "serverRequestCall: doing delayed cleanup."
-              free callPtr
-              C.destroyCallDetails callDetails
-              C.metadataArrayDestroy metadataArrayPtr
-              return ()

src/Network/GRPC/LowLevel/Server.hs

@@ -126,18 +126,16 @@ serverRegisterMethod _ _ _ _ = error "Streaming methods not implemented yet."
 -- method.
 serverCreateCall :: Server
                  -> RegisteredMethod
-                 -> TimeoutSeconds
                  -> IO (Either GRPCIOError ServerCall)
-serverCreateCall Server{..} rm timeLimit =
+serverCreateCall Server{..} rm =
-  serverRequestCall internalServer serverCQ timeLimit rm
+  serverRequestCall internalServer serverCQ rm
 
 withServerCall :: Server
                -> RegisteredMethod
-               -> TimeoutSeconds
                -> (ServerCall -> IO (Either GRPCIOError a))
                -> IO (Either GRPCIOError a)
-withServerCall server regmethod timeout f = do
+withServerCall server regmethod f = do
-  createResult <- serverCreateCall server regmethod timeout
+  createResult <- serverCreateCall server regmethod
   case createResult of
     Left x -> return $ Left x
     Right call -> f call `finally` logDestroy call
@@ -177,22 +175,21 @@ type ServerHandler
 -- | Wait for and then handle a normal (non-streaming) call.
 serverHandleNormalCall :: Server
                        -> RegisteredMethod
-                       -> TimeoutSeconds
                        -> MetadataMap
                        -- ^ Initial server metadata
                        -> ServerHandler
                        -> IO (Either GRPCIOError ())
-serverHandleNormalCall s@Server{..} rm timeLimit initMeta f = do
+serverHandleNormalCall s@Server{..} rm initMeta f = do
-  withServerCall s rm timeLimit $ \call -> do
+  withServerCall s rm $ \call -> do
     grpcDebug "serverHandleNormalCall(R): starting batch."
     debugServerCall call
-    payload <- serverCallGetPayload call
+    let payload = optionalPayload call
     case payload of
       --TODO: what should we do with an empty payload? Have the handler take
       -- @Maybe ByteString@? Need to figure out when/why payload would be empty.
       Nothing -> error "serverHandleNormalCall(R): payload empty."
       Just requestBody -> do
-        requestMeta <- serverCallGetMetadata call
+        let requestMeta = requestMetadataRecv call
         (respBody, trailingMeta, status, details) <- f call
                                                        requestBody
                                                        requestMeta

src/Network/GRPC/LowLevel/Server/Unregistered.hs

@@ -13,16 +13,15 @@ import           Network.GRPC.LowLevel.Op                           (Op(..), OpR
 import           Network.GRPC.LowLevel.Server                       (Server (..))
 import qualified Network.GRPC.Unsafe.Op                             as C
 
-serverCreateCall :: Server -> TimeoutSeconds
+serverCreateCall :: Server -> IO (Either GRPCIOError ServerCall)
-                    -> IO (Either GRPCIOError ServerCall)
+serverCreateCall Server{..} =
-serverCreateCall Server{..} timeLimit =
+  serverRequestCall internalServer serverCQ
-  serverRequestCall internalServer serverCQ timeLimit
 
-withServerCall :: Server -> TimeoutSeconds
+withServerCall :: Server
                   -> (ServerCall -> IO (Either GRPCIOError a))
                   -> IO (Either GRPCIOError a)
-withServerCall server timeout f = do
+withServerCall server f = do
-  createResult <- serverCreateCall server timeout
+  createResult <- serverCreateCall server
   case createResult of
     Left x -> return $ Left x
     Right call -> f call `finally` logDestroy call
@@ -52,37 +51,29 @@ serverOpsSendNormalResponse body metadata code details =
 -- | A handler for an unregistered server call; bytestring arguments are the
 -- request body and response body respectively.
 type ServerHandler
-  =  ServerCall -> ByteString -> MetadataMap -> MethodName
+  =  ServerCall -> ByteString
   -> IO (ByteString, MetadataMap, C.StatusCode, StatusDetails)
 
 -- | Handle one unregistered call.
 serverHandleNormalCall :: Server
-                       -> TimeoutSeconds
                        -> MetadataMap -- ^ Initial server metadata.
                        -> ServerHandler
                        -> IO (Either GRPCIOError ())
-serverHandleNormalCall s@Server{..} timeLimit srvMetadata f = do
+serverHandleNormalCall s@Server{..} srvMetadata f = do
-  withServerCall s timeLimit $ \call -> do
+  withServerCall s $ \call@ServerCall{..} -> do
     grpcDebug "serverHandleNormalCall(U): starting batch."
     let recvOps = serverOpsGetNormalCall srvMetadata
-        call'   = unServerCall call
+    opResults <- runOps unServerCall serverCQ recvOps
-    opResults <- runOps call' serverCQ recvOps
     case opResults of
       Left x -> do grpcDebug "serverHandleNormalCall(U): ops failed; aborting"
                    return $ Left x
       Right [OpRecvMessageResult (Just body)] -> do
-        requestMeta <- serverCallGetMetadata call
+        grpcDebug $ "got client metadata: " ++ show requestMetadataRecv
-        grpcDebug $ "got client metadata: " ++ show requestMeta
+        grpcDebug $ "call_details host is: " ++ show callHost
-        methodName <- serverCallGetMethodName call
+        (respBody, respMetadata, status, details) <- f call body
-        hostName <- serverCallGetHost call
-        grpcDebug $ "call_details host is: " ++ show hostName
-        (respBody, respMetadata, status, details) <- f call
-                                                       body
-                                                       requestMeta
-                                                       methodName
         let respOps = serverOpsSendNormalResponse
                         respBody respMetadata status details
-        respOpsResults <- runOps call' serverCQ respOps
+        respOpsResults <- runOps unServerCall serverCQ respOps
         case respOpsResults of
           Left x -> do grpcDebug "serverHandleNormalCall(U): resp failed."
                        return $ Left x

src/Network/GRPC/Unsafe.chs

@@ -2,6 +2,7 @@
 
 module Network.GRPC.Unsafe where
 
+import Control.Exception (bracket)
 import Control.Monad
 
 import Foreign.C.Types
@@ -46,6 +47,9 @@ deriving instance Show CallDetails
 {#fun create_call_details as ^ {} -> `CallDetails'#}
 {#fun destroy_call_details as ^ {`CallDetails'} -> `()'#}
 
+withCallDetails :: (CallDetails -> IO a) -> IO a
+withCallDetails = bracket createCallDetails destroyCallDetails
+
 -- instance def adapted from
 -- https://mail.haskell.org/pipermail/c2hs/2007-June/000800.html
 instance Storable Call where

tests/LowLevelTests.hs

@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ import           Control.Monad
 import           Data.ByteString                           (ByteString)
 import qualified Data.Map                                  as M
 import           Network.GRPC.LowLevel
+import qualified Network.GRPC.LowLevel.Call.Unregistered   as U
 import qualified Network.GRPC.LowLevel.Client.Unregistered as U
 import qualified Network.GRPC.LowLevel.Server.Unregistered as U
 import           Test.Tasty
@@ -29,9 +30,6 @@ lowLevelTests = testGroup "Unit tests of low-level Haskell library"
   , testClientCall
   , testClientTimeoutNoServer
   , testServerCreateDestroy
-  , testServerCall
-  , testServerTimeoutNoClient
-  , testWrongEndpoint
   , testMixRegisteredUnregistered
   , testPayload
   , testPayloadUnregistered
@@ -65,42 +63,12 @@ testClientTimeoutNoServer =
   clientOnlyTest "request timeout when server DNE" $ \c -> do
     rm <- clientRegisterMethod c "/foo" Normal
     r  <- clientRequest c rm 1 "Hello" mempty
-    r @?= Left GRPCIOUnknownError
+    r @?= Left GRPCIOTimeout
 
 testServerCreateDestroy :: TestTree
 testServerCreateDestroy =
   serverOnlyTest "start/stop" [] nop
 
-testServerCall :: TestTree
-testServerCall =
-  serverOnlyTest "create/destroy call" [] $ \s -> do
-    r <- U.withServerCall s 1 $ const $ return $ Right ()
-    r @?= Left GRPCIOTimeout
-
-testServerTimeoutNoClient :: TestTree
-testServerTimeoutNoClient =
-  serverOnlyTest "wait timeout when client DNE" [("/foo", Normal)] $ \s -> do
-    let rm = head (registeredMethods s)
-    r <- serverHandleNormalCall s rm 1 mempty dummyHandler
-    r @?= Left GRPCIOTimeout
-
-testWrongEndpoint :: TestTree
-testWrongEndpoint =
-  csTest "client requests unknown endpoint" client server [("/foo", Normal)]
-  where
-    -- TODO: possibly factor out dead-simple client/server construction even
-    -- further
-    client c = do
-      rm <- clientRegisterMethod c "/bar" Normal
-      r  <- clientRequest c rm 1 "Hello!" mempty
-      r @?= Left (GRPCIOBadStatusCode StatusDeadlineExceeded
-                    (StatusDetails "Deadline Exceeded"))
-    server s = do
-      length (registeredMethods s) @?= 1
-      let rm = head (registeredMethods s)
-      r <- serverHandleNormalCall s rm 2 mempty dummyHandler
-      r @?= Left GRPCIOTimeout
-
 testMixRegisteredUnregistered :: TestTree
 testMixRegisteredUnregistered =
   csTest "server uses unregistered calls to handle unknown endpoints"
@@ -119,28 +87,21 @@ testMixRegisteredUnregistered =
       clientRequest c rm2 1 "bad endpoint" mempty >>= do
         checkReqRslt $ \NormalRequestResult{..} -> do
           rspBody @?= ""
-      r3 <- clientRequest c rm1 1 "Hello" mempty
-      r3 @?= deadlineExceededStatus
       return ()
     server s = do
        concurrently regThread unregThread
        return ()
        where regThread = do
                let rm = head (registeredMethods s)
-               r <- serverHandleNormalCall s rm 2 dummyMeta $ \_ body _ -> do
+               r <- serverHandleNormalCall s rm dummyMeta $ \_ body _ -> do
                  body @?= "Hello"
                  return ("reply test", dummyMeta, StatusOk, StatusDetails "")
                return ()
              unregThread = do
-               r1 <- U.serverHandleNormalCall s 2 mempty $ \_ _ _ method -> do
+               r1 <- U.serverHandleNormalCall s mempty $ \call _ -> do
-                 method @?= "/bar"
+                 U.callMethod call @?= "/bar"
                  return ("", mempty, StatusOk,
                          StatusDetails "Wrong endpoint")
-               r2 <- U.serverHandleNormalCall s 2 mempty $ \_ _ _ method -> do
-                 method @?= "/bar"
-                 return ("", mempty, StatusNotFound,
-                         StatusDetails "Wrong endpoint")
-               r2 @?= Left GRPCIOTimeout
                return ()
 
 -- TODO: There seems to be a race here (and in other client/server pairs, of
@@ -166,7 +127,7 @@ testPayload =
     server s = do
       length (registeredMethods s) @?= 1
       let rm = head (registeredMethods s)
-      r <- serverHandleNormalCall s rm 11 dummyMeta $ \_ reqBody reqMD -> do
+      r <- serverHandleNormalCall s rm dummyMeta $ \_ reqBody reqMD -> do
         reqBody @?= "Hello!"
         checkMD "Server metadata mismatch" clientMD reqMD
         return ("reply test", dummyMeta, StatusOk,
@@ -185,9 +146,9 @@ testServerCancel =
                                           "Received RST_STREAM err=8"))
     server s = do
       let rm = head (registeredMethods s)
-      r <- serverHandleNormalCall s rm 10 mempty $ \c _ _ -> do
+      r <- serverHandleNormalCall s rm mempty $ \c _ _ -> do
         serverCallCancel c StatusCancelled ""
-        return (mempty, mempty, StatusOk, "")
+        return (mempty, mempty, StatusCancelled, "")
       r @?= Right ()
 
 testPayloadUnregistered :: TestTree
@@ -201,9 +162,9 @@ testPayloadUnregistered =
           rspBody @?= "reply test"
           details @?= "details string"
     server s = do
-      r <- U.serverHandleNormalCall s 11 mempty $ \_ body _md meth -> do
+      r <- U.serverHandleNormalCall s mempty $ \U.ServerCall{..} body -> do
              body @?= "Hello!"
-             meth @?= "/foo"
+             callMethod @?= "/foo"
              return ("reply test", mempty, StatusOk, "details string")
       r @?= Right ()
 
@@ -223,10 +184,12 @@ testGoaway =
         lastResult == unavailableStatus
         ||
         lastResult == deadlineExceededStatus
+        ||
+        lastResult == Left GRPCIOTimeout
     server s = do
       let rm = head (registeredMethods s)
-      serverHandleNormalCall s rm 11 mempty dummyHandler
+      serverHandleNormalCall s rm mempty dummyHandler
-      serverHandleNormalCall s rm 11 mempty dummyHandler
+      serverHandleNormalCall s rm mempty dummyHandler
       return ()
 
 testSlowServer :: TestTree
@@ -239,7 +202,7 @@ testSlowServer =
       result @?= deadlineExceededStatus
     server s = do
       let rm = head (registeredMethods s)
-      serverHandleNormalCall s rm 1 mempty $ \_ _ _ -> do
+      serverHandleNormalCall s rm mempty $ \_ _ _ -> do
         threadDelay (2*10^(6 :: Int))
         return ("", mempty, StatusOk, StatusDetails "")
       return ()
@@ -254,7 +217,7 @@ testServerCallExpirationCheck =
       return ()
     server s = do
       let rm = head (registeredMethods s)
-      serverHandleNormalCall s rm 5 mempty $ \c _ _ -> do
+      serverHandleNormalCall s rm mempty $ \c _ _ -> do
         exp1 <- serverCallIsExpired c
         assertBool "Call isn't expired when handler starts" $ not exp1
         threadDelaySecs 1
@@ -263,7 +226,7 @@ testServerCallExpirationCheck =
         threadDelaySecs 3
         exp3 <- serverCallIsExpired c
         assertBool "Call is expired after 4 seconds" exp3
-        return ("", mempty, StatusDetails "")
+        return ("", mempty, StatusCancelled, StatusDetails "")
       return ()
 
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

tests/LowLevelTests/Op.hs

@@ -84,7 +84,7 @@ withClientServerUnaryCall grpc f = do
         -- created. If later we want to send payloads or metadata, we'll need
         -- to tweak this.
         clientRes <- runOps (unClientCall cc) (clientCQ c) clientEmptySendOps
-        withServerCall s srm 10 $ \sc ->
+        withServerCall s srm $ \sc ->
           f (c, s, cc, sc)
 
 serverConf = (ServerConfig "localhost" 50051 [("/foo", Normal)])